I consistently completely turn off my cellphone upon entering a movie theater. Not simply on silent mode – all the way off. I share this not from a place of judgment, or in the hope that the ghost of Billy Wilder will return to offer approval. I see it as one of life's minor indulgences: for a minimum of an hour and a half, I am completely disconnected. I leave my phone off during the scroll as well. It seems luxurious to linger as other patrons slowly filter out, illuminated solely by the scrolling names.
And, lately, by the glow of the cataloguing app.
More than millions of users utilize Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing platform. Like the Criterion Collection, it has become a marker for a particular kind of aficionado who champions fresh cinema and finds joy in revisiting vintage films. Patrons score and write about films, and the funniest or most illuminating reviews ascend to the top, motivating cinephiles to write diligently.
"Unless I jot down my ideas promptly when the film concludes, my critiques are much less clear and eloquent," said one user.
During a recent visit to the theater, the credits had barely started before the patron ahead of me commenced writing his review. A few seats over, a couple sat, focused on their screens, noting their individual impressions.
The renowned film-maker David Lynch shared some guidance: write down every spark of inspiration the precise instant it comes to mind. Otherwise, it could slip your mind, and, as he put it: "Losing a valuable thought, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to hopeful creators, this mindset fits the act of reviewing.
Josh Stern, a young university attendee in New York, without fail writes his critiques while still in the cinema.
"If I don't get my thoughts out quickly when the film concludes, my critiques are much less coherent and articulate," he said. "It requires a while. I take my time, and my girlfriend gets impatient."
He goes to the movies a great deal – on 182 occasions in a single year – and is on a first-name basis with the theater staff, who occasionally must usher him out so they can begin cleaning the rows. He thinks it perfectly fair to utilize the closing scroll: "When you pay for a movie ticket, the credits are included in the movie."
The platform's most ardent supporters give credit to the app with rekindling interest around a battered cinema sector, where productions are down and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also boasts the type of demographics brands seek – its primary group of users is aged 18 and 24, then 25 to 35.)
Excitement begets more hype; highly awaited movies experience a rash of reviews on Letterboxd shortly following the initial screenings. The highest-rated critique of an acclaimed film version – "the author passed away in the 19th century yet this adaptation is still the most egregious event that has ever happened to her" – has amassed in excess of 50,000 hearts. A separate pop culture movie produced this juxtaposition to a rival's concert film: "that other tour film discovered deceased."
"It feels like a habit," commented a marketing professional, a 33-year-old New Yorker who works in marketing. He also chooses to write reviews during the credits. "Reflecting on what you just witnessed, immediately after you watched it, helps with the viewing experience. It helps you grasp the central themes of a film. If it evokes a feeling of a warm hug, that's hardly something you remember five hours down the line."
He feels most motivated to critique a film if it was exceptionally good – or terrible. As an illustration: he recently watched a sci-fi film. "I was so disappointed by how utterly terrible it was, that I was keen to take out my phone and assign it a lowest possible rating," he noted. (He is a tougher critic than other film critics, who assigned the film a higher rating, describing it as "smart and entertaining material.")
Dakota Chester, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who is in social media, viewed a fantasy movie at a cinema on the Upper West Side and lingered to write the assessment ("it received a perfect score"). He has observed more egregious conduct: people whipping out their phones to Letterboxd the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That gets on my nerves," he said.
One of film's most persistent tales tells of a screening of a pioneering film that depicted a train pulling into a station. Film was in its infancy and – according to this debunked story – the footage of a locomotive charging directly toward the camera shocked the audience so much that people ran away screaming.
Many decades later, audience behavior can be just as problematic. Apparently, individuals understand how to conduct themselves anymore, particularly when the theater darkens: viewers use their phones of the image, carry in odorous food, and, as occurred during a blockbuster summer, at times participate in fights.
A number of users have taken to social media to debate the appropriateness of writing reviews in the closing scroll. When one social media user